http://worldarea.info/2009/06/scientists-found-mysterious-forms-of-water/ world area Mon, 10 Aug 2009 03:19:49 +0000 http://wordpress.org/?v=2.9.1 hourly 1 http://worldarea.info/2009/06/scientists-found-mysterious-forms-of-water/comment-page-1/#comment-145 Jay Mann Mon, 29 Jun 2009 15:16:16 +0000 http://worldarea.info/?p=328#comment-145 Be very Careful about the data. Remember the anomalous water (polywater) excitement of the 1960-70 or so, which turned out to be a contamination problem. TEMPOL is a small molecule but not so small as water. The ESR spectrum must be carefully fit! And other known amounts of TEMPOL the water should be ultra pure - and that can be a problem. They may have an interesting result but the effect of environmental contamination must be understood before the results can be believed. This article leaves too much dangling - especially in view of the bad science of the polywater story. What is the Citation, if any? Jay Mann Be very Careful about the data. Remember the anomalous water (polywater) excitement of the 1960-70 or so, which turned out to be a contamination problem. TEMPOL is a small molecule but not so small as water. The ESR spectrum must be carefully fit! And other known amounts of TEMPOL the water should be ultra pure – and that can be a problem. They may have an interesting result but the effect of environmental contamination must be understood before the results can be believed. This article leaves too much dangling – especially in view of the bad science of the polywater story. What is the Citation, if any?
Jay Mann

]]>